Opens in a new tab

Episode 74

Promoting Your Best Technician

Episode 74 looks at the move from doing skilled work to managing other people. Corinne Hale discusses what changes in the role and what the owner needs to provide during the first 90 days.

  • From doing the work to being judged by the team's work
  • Build the first 90 days around clear milestones
  • Give the new manager time to manage

The strongest technician knows the work, solves difficult problems and earns the crew’s respect. So the owner promotes that person to supervisor. Three weeks later, the new manager is still taking the hardest jobs while everyone waits for direction. The promotion changed the title but not the daily responsibilities. Episode 74 examines why technical ability and management responsibility are different jobs, and what an owner needs to make clear before expecting someone to lead other people.

Key points

  • Define what success now looks like. A technician is often judged by the work they personally complete. A manager is responsible for setting expectations, assigning work, following up and developing people. The owner must describe that change in concrete terms. Otherwise the new supervisor may continue to judge every day by the amount of hands-on work finished.
  • Use the first 30 days to establish relationships. The new manager holds a one-on-one with each person and agrees on expectations. The owner needs to clarify which decisions the manager can make, what must be discussed first and which matters still belong above the manager’s authority.
  • Change the workload during days 31 to 60. The new manager begins handing off tasks from the old technical role and establishes the team’s weekly meeting. If the owner continues assigning the most difficult technical jobs to that person, the management work competes for whatever time remains. Delegation is part of the promotion, not an optional extra.
  • Make feedback part of days 61 to 90. The manager gives first feedback to everyone and presents a 90-day plan to their own manager. Useful feedback identifies the situation, the observed behavior, its effect and the requested change. Matters involving discipline, pay, protected leave or complaints require appropriate human resources or legal guidance.
  • Manage the manager rather than the team. The owner’s job changes too. Hold regular one-on-ones with the new manager, ask for recommendations when problems arise and examine the manager’s scorecard. Going directly to employees with instructions can leave the new supervisor responsible for work they do not actually direct.

One thing to try this week

Meet with a recently promoted supervisor and ask them to describe what they believe they are now responsible for. Compare the answer with what you intended when you made the promotion. Write down three management responsibilities, the decisions they can make and the technical tasks that still need another owner. Choose one task to transfer and agree on the first check-in date. Put the next one-on-one on the calendar before the conversation ends.

Related reading

Throughline’s Leadership Scorecard is a two-page self-rating of 20 leadership habits. It helps identify three habits to work on first. For a new manager, that can make a useful starting conversation about the difference between technical competence and leading a team. The owner still has to provide clear authority, time for management work and regular feedback. A promotion by itself supplies none of those things.

Keep reading about the owner's role

Becoming a manager is a new job

Throughline coaches work with owners and managers on delegation, expectations and leadership habits. Start with a conversation about fit.