Managing people
Who decides what: writing down decision rights
A one-page list of decision rights helps managers see which weekly choices they make alone, make after asking, or bring as recommendations.
Imagine the owner of a commercial cleaning contractor in Sunrise Manor receiving calls about supply orders, schedule adjustments and customer credits. The supervisors know the work but are uncertain which decisions they can make without checking first. An ordinary Tuesday can bring several versions of the same question: “Is this mine to decide?”
A one-page list of decision rights helps answer that question by role. It names decisions that arise every week and marks each one as decides alone, decides after asking, or recommends. The owner writes the list with the managers and reviews it each quarter. The page is a working agreement about authority, not a prediction that every decision will become simple.
List the decisions that repeat
Start with decisions the business makes in an ordinary week. The list might include supply orders, schedule changes and customer credits in our cleaning contractor example. These are illustrations of recurring choices, not a proposed policy for every contractor. The owner and managers should identify what actually appears in their own week.
For each decision, specify the role that is expected to handle it. Avoid a line that just says “management approves.” That leaves the same question unresolved: which manager, and what kind of approval? A page is useful only when the people who use it can find the recurring decision and recognize their role.
Suppose a site supervisor regularly receives a request to adjust a cleaning schedule. The owner asks how the decision currently gets made. The supervisor says they usually call the office because they are unsure whether changing the order of visits is allowed. The owner writes “routine schedule adjustments” on the page for discussion. No authority has changed yet. They have simply named a decision both people recognize.
Use three clear markings
Each recurring decision receives one of three markings for the relevant role. These are categories on the decision rights page, not the separate five levels of authority used when handing off a particular task.
- Decides alone: The role makes the decision without asking someone else first, within whatever boundaries the owner and managers have agreed.
- Decides after asking: The role seeks input before making the decision. The person being asked contributes information, while the decision still belongs to the marked role.
- Recommends: The role brings a recommendation, and the owner or other designated leader keeps the decision.
For our schedule example, the owner and site supervisors might agree that certain routine adjustments belong under decides alone. A change affecting another site could be marked decides after asking. A different decision, such as a customer credit that the owner wants to retain, could be marked recommends. These are invented illustrations of how to read the page, not prescribed authority limits.
The important question is what each marking means when an actual request arrives. A supervisor who sees “recommends” knows to examine the issue and bring a view, rather than waiting without a proposal. A supervisor with “decides after asking” knows that hearing input comes before the decision, but making the call is still part of the role.
Write it with the managers
The owner should build this document with the people who will use it. Put the recurring decisions in front of the managers and discuss where authority already sits and where it is unclear. The manager’s description of a Tuesday afternoon may show that two roles think the other one makes the call.
In our example, one supervisor thinks the office manager must approve any supply request. The office manager thinks site supervisors already decide ordinary orders. The owner asks each person what they do now, then the group chooses the marking that reflects the authority they want to give that role. They write that choice on the same page.
When a manager asks about a particular situation, keep the conversation tied to the decision and the role. The owner may decide to retain it as recommends. That is a clear outcome too. Writing decision rights does not mean every approval moves away from the owner. It means the owner and managers can see which decisions belong where.
Review the page each quarter
Decision rights are reviewed each quarter, because roles and the work they handle can change. The owner and managers read through the page together. For each recurring decision, they ask whether the marking still describes who should decide and whether anyone is unsure how it works.
In the cleaning contractor example, a supervisor may now be comfortable handling a schedule adjustment that was previously marked decides after asking. The group can discuss changing the marking to decides alone. Or a particular customer decision may still need the owner’s approval. Either choice can be recorded without treating a changed marking as a measure of someone’s worth.
Where to start this week
Write down the approvals managers bring you during a normal workweek. Choose the recurring decisions and sit with the managers who handle them. Put each one on a single page, identify the role, and agree whether it decides alone, decides after asking, or recommends. Set a time to review that page next quarter.
More articles on delegation
Write down who decides what
Decision rights start with the owner and managers agreeing on recurring choices. Throughline coaching supports that work without making those decisions for them.

